Christmas is a season of love and warmth and a time for heated family disputes. Learn how to understand the forces that cause family arguments and have a peaceful holiday.
A happy family, so it goes, “is just an earlier heaven,” which makes an unhappy family an absolute hell.
Many of us are preparing for possible tension and arguments as we approach the holiday season. Family gatherings can bring out our worst traits, whether quiet disapproval of the food, simmering resentment about alleged favoritism, or a heated argument over political and social values. We rarely get to spend time with our family – many are forced to spend their holidays apart.
Although family conflict may provide entertainment in dramas such as Succession, the real-life consequences are not a joke.
The feeling of isolation is a typical result of estrangement, along with feelings of shame or being judged. Lucy Blake, a developmental psychologist and author of the upcoming book No Family Is Perfection: A Guide to Accepting the Messy Realities agrees.
It is not easy to repair a broken relationship. Understanding our family dynamics will help us prepare for inevitable stressors.
People tend to avoid discussing unhappy family gatherings or estrangement, which can make us feel that we’re somehow abnormal. Some people may think that it is our fault for having such bad relations. Blake says that social media can increase our feelings of loneliness. Blake says that we often see family members putting on a show, and this can make us feel isolated. Few people will post a photo of a fight. You’re more likely to find a picture with a gurning face before a meal, rather than a teary-eyed person after an argument.
However, anonymous surveys suggest that fractious relationships in families are surprisingly common. Blake cites a study from the US that asked 633 middle-aged Americans about their relationship with their parents and children. Nearly a third had little contact with their family, but most felt emotional ties, reporting both positive and negative feelings. Many of those who had more frequent contact described their relationship as “ambivalent” or “conflicted”. Only 28% were and harmonious.
A paper published earlier in the year examined data from a large longitudinal study conducted in Germany, to determine estrangement’s prevalence. Researchers defined estrangement as a lack of contact between a parent and teen, or less than monthly contact with a child combined with lowered emotional closeness. Using these criteria, approximately 20% of people experience estrangement with their fathers and 9% experience estrangement with their mothers.
Even mild family disputes can cause deep wounds. They tend to have some common causes.
A shared History
Even though any relationship can be tense, family disputes are often sparked by conflicting interpretations about the past. The smallest comment can bring this to the forefront. The emotional stakes in family relationships are much higher than those of friendships with people outside the clan.
Terri Apter is a UK-based psychologist and author of several books on strained family relationships. These include Difficult Mothers, The Sister Knot, and Difficult Mothers. There’s always a threat of losing status and connection in the family.
It is important to note that the way in which you express your frustrations will depend on where you are in the family tree. Parents may believe they are entitled to guide their adult children, whether it is about their career, appearance or romantic relationship. However, their well-meaning remarks may remind their child about constant unfair criticisms they received as an adolescent.
There may also have been competition between siblings over who received the most attention or felt the most dominant. You may think that your big brother still believes he is the expert, or that your little sister is acting up to get attention.
You might have a different perspective if you only experienced these events as a single event. You may find your brother’s advice irritating but it is well-intentioned. You might think that your sister’s tantrum was a blip and just a bad day. If you have a family history of resentment, you may feel stuck in a never-ending Groundhog Day where old crimes repeat themselves.
Apter says that it doesn’t take much to bring back patterns from the past. The fact that you may not like the way you respond to the behavior can exacerbate the tension and discomfort.
Clashing Family Cultures
Apter explains that interacting with in-laws can be challenging, as the rules of conduct of one family may seem strange to another. Some actions, such as who does the dishes or how you speak to different relatives, can be taken as givens. What passes for a joke in one family may come across as an insult in another.



